{Christmas Cookie Favorites} Lemon squares

Tis’ the season for baking……as a family that strives to keep junk food and sugary treats out of the house, Christmas time is a time I really let loose and bake our favorite goodies. By Christmas Eve I’ve usually baked at least 12 types of cookies (more or less) to give to friends and to take to different gatherings. I also manage to keep a few of each stashed away for our Christmas Eve family party. It’s so much fun, and a tradition we all look forward to every year. I always make sure to bake everyone’s top 3 cookie choices. I’ll be sharing a few of favorites over the next two weeks.

These lemon squares are one of my absolute favorites!! I was thrilled the first time I made them to find out how EASY they are to make (quick & easy!!) I found out last year that my father-in-law loves them too. It was the same conversation where I found out he prefers receiving homemade Christmas treats instead of the impersonal gift cards my hubby had been insisting we buy him each year. Yay!! I was able to get 3 favorites listed down that I can now make him every year. I’m pretty sure I only duplicate one of the ones my sister-in-law makes….her famous tollhouse brittle I’ll be sharing soon.

I’m pretty sure no one can resist these slightly tart but sweet lemon treats. Everyone loves lemon, right? I thought so too, but just found out my mother-in-law doesn’t. She must be the only one….anyone else not love lemon? It’s because of her that I experimented with orange zest cookies. They turned out pretty good. I got this lemon square recipe from one of my first online message board hang outs back in 2002.

If you homeschool, you’ve got to check out Five in a Row. If you love children books and you have elementary aged children, you must check them out!! Some of our BEST homeschool memories have been created using this inexpensive, yet creative homeschool curriculum. It’s so great that many non-homeschool families use it on the side to enrich their children’s lives.

Back to the lemon squares…..she titled them “Granny’s Lemon Squares” and the only change I make is that I double the recipe and use a 9 x 13 pan. I’m sharing that version with you because an 8 x 8 pan is really just a tease. I like to cut them small because they pack a powerful punch, and ensures everyone gets a taste. Plus a 9 x 13 pan gives you enough to take to 2 holiday events or 1 event and some for home. I already took them to the play my older girls were in last week (A Christmas Carol…my oldest was the ghost of Christmas past), and the end of the year party for our American Girl Club. They went fast, and I was asked if they were on my blog. 🙂

What are your favorite Christmas cookies? What’s on your “Must Make” list every year?

5.0 from 2 reviews
{Christmas Cookie Favorites} Lemon squares
Recipe type: Dessert, Christmas cookies
Prep time: 
Cook time: 
Total time: 
Serves: 60
These amazing bites of lemon bliss are hit at every party....you'll never have any to take home! They also make a perfect gift.
  • 2 cups all-purpose flour
  • ½ cup powdered sugar
  • 2 sticks butter, melted
  • 4 eggs
  • 2 cups sugar
  • 2 Tbsp flour
  • 6 Tbsp lemon juice
  1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees. Mix flour and powdered sugar. Melt butter and mix with flour and sugar. Press into a buttered 9 x 13 pan (I use pyrex). Bake for 18 - 20 minutes.
  2. Beat eggs, sugar, flour and lemon juice. Pour over baked crust. Bake for 20-25 minutes.
  3. Cool and sprinkle with more powdered sugar. When completely cool cut into small squares and serve. Makes about 60 small squares.

If you enjoyed this post, won’t you consider sharing it with others? Handy share and “Facebook recommend” buttons are below. It really makes my day when you pass things along! To make sure you don’t miss a post or recipe you can either follow Creative Kitchen on Facebook or subscribe by Email in the sidebar. Thanks for reading….I love having company in the kitchen!

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
Bookmark the permalink.

19 Responses to {Christmas Cookie Favorites} Lemon squares

  1. Gorgeous lemon squares! These are one of our favorites as well. Reminds me I need to make some with all the Meyer lemons I have on my tree right now.
    Lana @ Never Enough Thyme recently posted..Classic Peanut Brittle

  2. Terry says:

    Oooh, love these yummy treats! Thank you!

  3. Lemon bars are my fave! And they are less common at parties, so it is the perfect dish to bring.
    Allison (Allison’s Delicious Life) recently posted..Holiday Spirit: Quick Fixes

  4. Oh, I love these! I have never attempted to make them myself (I really should, right?), but whenever I see them at a bakery or the grocery store, I have to buy one. They are so buttery and lemony and good!
    ohkeeka [The Type A Housewife] recently posted..Recipe | Vegetarian Chicken Noodle Soup

  5. Pam Rauber says:

    These look fantastic. As I was reading your story, my glands actually started salivated. I could feel the sourness causing my mouth to pucker.

    Gonna make these.
    Pam Rauber recently posted..A Cookie Swap, A Fear of Being Black Listed and Losing Followers

  6. Velva says:

    Lemon squares are a family favorite. Thanks for the reminder that these need to be made for the Christmas food spread.

    Velva recently posted..Wordless Wednesday

  7. Mmmmmmm!!! Love love lemon bars! These look sublime!

  8. Lemon bars are like sunshine in the tummy!

  9. Bibi says:

    I love lemon squares….I usually make them like this, but this year I tries something different….little meringue layer on top…..they turned out great.
    Bibi recently posted..Hungarian Fried Bread ( Langoše)

  10. Emily says:

    DH loves lemon bars. I would make this recipe as I do any of the rare baked sweets that I make: with a mixture of honey and xylitol instead of sugar.
    Emily recently posted..What to expect from the Crunchy Coach Blog

  11. Pingback: {Christmas Cookie Favorites} Tollhouse Brittle | Creative Kitchen

  12. Pingback: {Christmas Cookie Favorites} Mint Chocolate Cookies | Creative Kitchen

  13. these look delicious!
    Diane {Created by Diane} recently posted..Baked Huevos Rancheros

  14. Patsy says:

    I love Lemon Bars, and this recipe sounds great! I am a new follower! Patsy
    Patsy recently posted..BLT Dip

  15. Pingback: Sweet treats I'm craving....desserts perfect for Easter weekend! | Creative Kitchen

  16. S. Kinzel says:

    Found your site yesterday; made it and served them last night. The squares went over really well. Will definately be making them again. It is great to find a simple, easy-to-make lemon recipe. Many thanks!

  17. Pingback: Easy crumb coffee cake | Creative Kitchen

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Rate this recipe:  

CommentLuv badge